Mark Sandrich: Film History

Mark Sandrich, “Shall We Dance”, May 7, 1937, Starring Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers, “They All Laughed” Dance Sequence, Film Clip Gifs, Cinematography David Abel and Joseph F. Bloc, Music George Gershwin, Lyrics Ira Gershwin, RKO Radio Pictures

Born in New York City in October of 1900, Mark Sandrich was an American film director, writer and producer. He is considered one of the most gifted and least heralded directors of the 1930s and early 1940s. A splendid technician, Sandrich’s cinematic craftsmanship and intuitive sense of rhythm helped chart the golden era of Hollywood musicals.

Born Mark Rex Goldstein, Mark Sandrich was the son of England-born Rabbi Jacob Goldstein and Hungarian-born Klara Jacobson Sandrich. Trained as a physicist at New York’s Columbia University, he began his career in the film industry in 1922 as a prop man after offering advice during a studio film shooting. Sandrich began directing short two-reel silent comedies in 1926 and 1927, the first of these being “Jerry the Giant” for Fox Film Corporation. In 1928, he directed his first feature film, the silent one-hour drama “Runaway Girls”, distributed by the newly founded Columbia Pictures.

Sandrich continued directing short films in 1929 and eventually directed more than thirty-five shorts by the middle of 1933. His first title as screenwriter was a co-credit with Nat Carr for the 1930 short film “Gunboat Ginsberg”. In 1933, Sandrich directed and co-wrote his last short film, “So This is Harris!”, a pre-code musical comedy produced by Lou Brock and released in August by RKO Radio Pictures. The film won an Oscar in 1934 for Best Short Subject (Comedy) at the 6th Academy Awards.

With the shooting of “So This is Harris!” finished, Mark Sandrich began to focus on feature films. In 1933, he directed his first feature film with sound, “Melody Cruise”, a successful musical comedy that established him as a commercial director. In the same year, Sandrich did some uncredited second unit work with Thornton Freeland’s musical “Flying Down to Rio” which, although they were not the headliners, was the first screen pairing of Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers. In 1934, he directed the first proper Astaire-Rogers musical “The Gay Divorcee”. This successful film received five Academy Award nominations, winning the Music (Song) Oscar for Con Conrad and Herb Magidson’s “The Continental”.

In 1935, Sandrich’s “Top Hat”, a film specifically written for Astaire and Rogers, was released to major box office success. In addition to its many dance numbers, this Oscar-nominated musical included comedic scenes that added to its appeal. Sandrich followed this film with the 1936 “Follow the Fleet”, an Astaire-Rogers film that featured Lucille Ball and Betty Grable in early screen roles. He reunited Astaire and Rogers in two more films: the 1937 “Shall We Dance” with orchestral work and lyrics by George and Ira Gershwin, and Sandrich’s last collaboration with the dance duo, “Carefree”, which focused less on musical numbers and more on comedy.

Mark Sandrich directed three comedy musicals featuring comedian Jack Benny: the 1939 “Man About Town” and, both in 1940, “Buck Benny Rides Again” and “Love Thy Neighbor”. His 1941 skillful romantic comedy for Paramount Pictures, “Skylark”, featured Claudette Colbert and Ray Milland. In 1941, Sandrich directed one of his best and probably most watched film, the musical :Holiday Inn” with Bing Crosby and Fred Astaire. An enormous success, the film featured Irving Berlin’s Oscar-winning song “White Christmas”.

During the years of World War II, Sandrich produced several films, the first of which was the 1943 “Proudly We Hail”, a patriotic drama about a group of nurses in the Pacific war zone. Paulette Goddard was nominated for an Academy Award for her supporting role as nurse Lt. Joan O’Doul. In 1944, Sandrich directed two films, the 1944 “Here Come the Waves”, a musical comedy featuring Bing Crosby and Betty Hutton, and “I Love A Soldier”, a soap opera set in the war with Paulette Goddard and Sonny Tufts.

In 1945, Mark Sandrich began pre-production work on the Irving Berlin musical “Blue Skies” with Fred Astaire and Bing Crosby. At that time, he was also serving as president of the Directors Guild as well as attempting to maintain a good family life with his wife and two sons. One of the most influential and trusted Hollywood directors, Mark Sandrich died suddenly of a heart attack on the fourth of March at the age of forty-four. His body was interred at the Home of Peace Memorial Park in East Los Angeles, California.

Notes: Mark Sandrich’s sister Ruth Harriet Louise (Goldstein) was the first woman photographer active in Hollywood and, later, chief studio portrait photographer for Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Studios. His two sons, Mark Sandrich Jr. and Jay Sandrich, are both directors in film and television.

Top Insert Image: Photographer Unknown, “Mark Sandrich on Set”, Studio Photo, Gelatin Silver Print

Second Insert Image: Mark Sandrich, “Here Come the Waves”, December 1944, Film Poster, Cinematography Charles Lang, Music Harold Arlen and Johnny Mercer, Paramount Pictures

Third Insert Image: Mark Sandrich, “Melody Cruise”, June 1933, Film Poster, Cinematography Bert Glennon, Music Max Steiner, RKO Radio Pictures

Bottom Insert Image: Mark Sandrich, “Holiday Inn”, August 1942, Film Poster, Cinematography David Abel, Music Irving Berlin, Paramount Pictures

Stellan Rye and “Der Student von Prag”: Film History Series

Josef Fenneker, Lithograph Film Poster for Arthur Robison’s 1935 Version of “Der Student von Prag”, Deutsche Kimemathek, Museum für Film and Fernsehen, Berlin

Born in July of 1880 at the Danish city of Randers, Stellan Rye was a film director and screenwriter active during the early twentieth-century. In his short career, he wrote and directed three productions: the 1913 “Der Student von Prag (The Student of Prague)”; the 1914 “Der Flug in die Sonne (The Flight into the Sun)”; and the 1914 “Ein Sommernachtstraum in Unserer Zeit (A Midsummer Night’s Dream in Our Time)”, co-written with German actor and horror novelist Hanns Heinz Ewers.

Rye joined the Reichsheer, the German Army, at the onset of World War I. Taken prisoner almost immediately, he died as a prisoner of war in France on the fourteenth of November in 1914 at the age of thirty-four.

Stellan Rye is best known for the 1913 German silent horror film “Der Student von Prag”, considered to be the first German art film, a pioneering work that raised cinema from its fairground origins to a viable art form. The film is loosely based on several literary works: Alfred de Musset’s poem “The December Night”, Edgar Allen Poe’s short story “William Wilson”, and the German legend of the Renaissance alchemist and magician Johann Georg Faust.

“Der Student von Prag” featured German actor Paul Wegener in his debut film role as the poor university student Balduin. He acted alongside Austrian actor John Gottowt in the role of Scapinelli, and Austrian-German actress Grete Berger as Balduin’s love interest Countess Margit. “Der Student von Prag” was art director and set designer Robert A. Dietrich’s first production in a career that spanned more than a hundred films. The film was shot on locations around Prague and at the Babelsberg Studios, now the oldest large-scale film studio in the world, having produced films since 1912.

In this horror story, poverty stricken Balduin signs a contract with the diabolical Scapinelli that will award Balduin one hundred-thousand gold pieces in exchange for any item in his lodgings. Scapinelli, dressed in all black, chooses Balduin’s reflection in the mirror and takes it away. During his courtship of Countess Margit, Balduin and Magrit are terrorized by his mirror double. Magrit, too frightened by the sudden appearances of the double, discontinues the courtship. Depressed, Balduin shoots his double with a pistol and it vanishes. However, Balduin himself becomes stricken and falls dead. The evil Scapinelli arrives, tears up the contract and departs happily.

German cinematographer Guido Seeber employed new technical camera effects of seamless double exposures to create one of his most notable accomplishments, the doppelgänger image of Balduin’s mirror double. An accomplished technician and a pioneer in his field, he also employed chiaroscuro, sharp contrasts between light and shadow, to create distinct areas on the sets. Hungarian composer and pianist Josef Weiss wrote the historic piano score that accompanied “Der Student von Prag”; it was the first film score written for a German language film.

Stellan Rye’s “Der Student von Prag” was both a critical and commercial success. The film tapped into the real sense of dissociation and alienation that was prominent in a society struggling with the collapse of the German Empire. The themes of the film became a major influence on German cinema produced during the years of the Weimar Republic. The insecurity and social changes that followed the deaths and devastation of the first World War became major themes for post-war German film makers.

Expressionism, developed as an avant-garde style before the war, remained popular during the Weimar Republic and extended to a wide range of the arts, including music, literature, dance and architecture. Stellan Rye’s “Der Student von Prag” was remade twice: Austrian Expressionist director Henrik Galeen’s 1926 version with Conrad Veidt, and German director Arthur Robison’s 1935 version with Austrian actor Anton Walbrook. Other notable films produced during this time period included Robert Wiene’s 1920 “The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari” and two films by Fritz Lang, the two-part 1922 “Dr. Mabuse”, and the 1927 “Metropolis”.

Notes: All insert images are film stills from the original 1913 “Der Student von Prag”, directed by Stellan Rye, that featured Paul Wegener, John Gottowt and Grete Berger.

A full-length version, with subtitles, of Stellan Rye’s “Der Student von Prag” can be found on the Internet Archive site located at: https://archive.org/details/der-student-von-prag-1913

Actress Grete Berger, born Margarethe Berg into an Austrian Jewish family, began her career in 1904 at the Deutsches Theater under prominent film and theater director Max Reinhardt. She was cast in several films directed by Stellan Rye or Paul Wegener, among which was her role in the 1913 “Der Student von Prag”. After the accession of power by the National Socialists in 1933, Berger fled with her husband to Italy where in April of 1944 they were arrested by the German occupational authorities. She was transferred, along with Austrian-Hungarian actor Jacob Feldhammer, in May of 1944 to the Auschwitz concentration camp where they were murdered on the twenty-third of May in 1944.

An 2023 article on Anton Walbrook, who performed the role of Balduin in Robinson’s 1935 version of “Der Student von Prag”, is located in the Film History Series of this site. A well known German actor who acted alongside some of Germany’s leading ladies, Walbrook, who was homosexual and the son of a Jewish mother, left Germany in 1936 to work for many years in the United States and England.

Rouben Mamoulian: Film History Series

Robert Mamoulian, “Dr Jekyll and Mr. Hyde”, December 1931, Cinematography Karl Struss, Music Herman Hand/ Johann Sebastian Bach, Running Time 90 Minutes, Paramount Pictures

Born in October of 1897 at the Georgian city of Tiflis in the Russian Empire, Rouben Mamoulian was a theatrical and film director noted for his contributions to cinematic art at the beginning of the sound era. Escaping the Soviet regime, he fled to England and later immigrated to the United States where he established his film career.

Born to an ethnic Armenian family, Rouben Mamoulian studied criminal law at the University of Moscow. Interested in theater, he trained at the Moscow Art Theatre under theatrical director Yevgeny Bagrationovich Vakhtangov who produced some of the most original and bold productions of Russian theater after the Revolution. In 1918, Mamoulian founded a drama studio in his hometown of Tiflis, now Tbilisi. In 1920, he toured with the Russian Repertory Company to England, where he stayed to study drama at the University of London.

Mamoulian began directing English stage productions in 1922. In the following year, he immigrated to the United States and became, at George Eastman’s request, the director of the American Opera Company in Rochester, New York. From 1925 to 1926, Mamoulian was head of Eastman’s School of Dance and Dramatic Action. During the late 1920s, he taught drama and directed productions at New York City’s Theater Guild. Mamoulian established himself in theatrical circles with his all-black cast production of Dorothy and Dubose Heyward’s 1927 “Porgy”. He would later direct George Gershwin’s 1935 Broadway production of “Porgy and Bess”.

Rouben Mamoulian, in addition to his theater work, directed Paramount Pictures’s 1929 early sound film “Applause” at their Astoria Studio in Queens, New York. For his film debut, he decided that stylization would be better than realism if done with flourish and skill. For the opening scene of this story, Mamoulian employed a roving camera in a soundproof booth that tracked along a desolate street before turning to follow the sound of a marching brass band. A cutaway in the film then transports the audience to a band practicing in a seedy theater.

In addition to defying the wisdom of a stationary camera, Mamoulian recorded the dialogue on separate microphones and combined them in post-production. He also employed sounds at the end of scenes that anticipated the action about to happen. In order to impose spatial depth, rhythm and momentum to the film, Mamooulian overlaid scenes with sounds of train doors opening, car horns blaring and people singing in the background. This innovation, seemingly simple by today’s standards, made a bold cinematic statement in 1929 when the sound era was just developing.

In 1931, Rouben Mamoulian directed “City Streets” for Paramount. This pre-code gangster film was written by famed detective-mystery author Dashiell Hammett; it featured Sylvia Sidney and the rising star Gary Cooper as the carnival worker who falls in love with the racketeer’s daughter. In the same year, Mamoulian directed the first sound version of Robert Louis Stevenson’s “Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde”. Considered by many critics as Mamoulian’s masterpiece, the film is known for Fredric March’s transformation between characters, made possible by Mamoulian’s innovative makeup and lighting effects. March was a winner, along with Wallace Beery in Vidor’s “The Champ”, for the Best Actor at the 1932 Academy Awards.

Mamoulian directed two more films for Paramount; the 1932 “Love Me Tonight”, one of the most accomplished of the early musicals due to his seamless blending of action and songs; and the 1933 “The Song of Songs”, a melodrama with Marlene Dietrich that was not well received by critics. Working now for Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, Mamoulian directed Greta Garbo in the 1933 biography “Queen Christina” and had great success with the 1935 “Becky Sharp”, an adaption of the novel “Vanity Fair”, which was the first feature released in Technicolor. After three more films with MGM that were not well received by the critics, Mamoulian took his talents to Twentieth-Century Fox.

Rouben Mamoulian directed two distinguished films for his new studio: the 1940 swashbuckler “The Mark of Zorro” with great performances by Tyrone Power, Linda Darnell and Basil Rathbone; and the 1941 “Blood and Sand”, a pageant of the rise and fall of a bullfighter which reunited Power and Darnell and also starred Rita Hayworth. After Otto Preminger secured the rights to Vera Caspary’s novel “Laura”, Darryl F. Zanuck approved Mamoulian to direct the film with Preminger as the producer. When problems developed between the cast and director, Mamoulian was fired and Preminger reshot all the footage.

Through his career, Mamoulian felt strongly that a director should be given creative freedom; he was never tolerant of creative interference. Disillusioned with Hollywood, he returned to Broadway where he directed two major musical hits, the 1943 “Oklahoma!” and the 1945 “Carousel”. Mamoulian directed just two more films for MGM: “Summer Holiday” in 1948 and the 1957 musical “Silk Stockings”, which starring Fred Astaire and Cyd Charisse, featured music and lyrics by Cole Porter. Although he was scheduled to direct the 1958 film version of “Porgy and Bess”, the position of director was given to Preminger. In 1963, Mamoulian began shooting the 1963 epic “Cleopatra”; however, after six days of shooting, he was replaced with Joseph L. Mankiewicz. This was Mamoulian’s last involvement with a Hollywood film production.

Rouben Mamoulian was personally recruited in 1936 by the Directors Guild of America’s co-founder King Vidor to help organize fellow movie directors. His strong allegiance to the Guild and unwillingness to compromise led to his being targeted in the 1950s Hollywood blacklisting. Mamoulian died of natural causes in December of 1987 at the Motion Picture & Television Country House and Hospital in Woodland Hills, California.

Note: Senses of Cinema, an online film site with interviews and extensive biographies of both actors and directors, has an interesting article on the 1929 “Applause”. Senses of Cinema can be found at: https://www.sensesofcinema.com/2002/cteq/applause/

Senses of Cinema also has an article on Mamoulian’s “Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde” which can be found at: https://www.sensesofcinema.com/2002/cteq/jekyll/

Top Insert Image: Rouben Mamoulian, Self Portrait, circa 1939, Vintage Black and White Print, 20.3 x 25.4 cm, Private Collection

Second Insert Image: Rouben Mamoulian, “Myrna Loy”, 1932, “Love Me Tonight”, Cinematography Victor Milner, 104 Minutes, Paramount Pictures

Third Insert Image: Rouben Mamoulian, “Fredric March”, 1931, “Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde”, Cinematography Karl Struss, 98 Minutes, Paramount Pictures

Fourth Insert Image: Rouben Mamoulian, “Gary Cooper and Sylvia Sidney”, 1931, “City Streets”, Cinematography Lee Garmes, 83 Minutes, Paramount Pictures

Bottom Insert Image: Rouben Mamoulian, “Tyrone Power”, 1940, “The Mask of Zorro”, Cinematography Arthur C. Miller, 94 Minutes, Twentieth-Century Fox