Robert Duncan: “It Was the Sound of Fire on the Hearth”

Photographers Unknown, Food for Fire, Food for Thought

      good wood
      that all fiery youth bust forth from winter,
         go to sleep in the poem.
      Who will remember thy green flame,
         thy dream’s amber?

Language obeyd flares tongues in obscure matter.

      We trace faces in clouds: they drift apart.
      Palaces of air. The sun dying down
         sets them on fire.

      Descry shadows on the flood from its dazzling mood,
      or at its shore read runes upon the sand
         from sea-spume.

This is what I wanted for the last poem.
A loosening of conventions and return to open form.

      Leonardo saw figures that were stains upon a wall
      Let the apparitions containd in the ground
         play as they will.

You have carried a branch of tomorrow into the room.
Its frangrance had awakend me. No. .

      It was the sound of a fire on the hearth
      Leapd up where you bankd it
      . . .sparks of delight. Now I return the thought

to the red glow, that might-be-magical blood,
palaces of heat in the fire’s mouth,

If you look you will see the salamander–

to the very elements that attend us,
fairies of the fire, the radiant crawling. .

That was a long time ago.
No. They were never really there,

      though once I saw–did I stare
      into the hear of desire burning
      and see a radiant man? like those
      fancy cities from fire into fire falling.

We are close enough to childhood, so easily purged
of whatever we thought we were to be.

Flamey threads of firstness go out from your touch,

flickers of unlikely heat
at the edge of our belief bud forth.

Robert Duncan, Food for Fire, Food for Thought, October 1959, Poetry, Volume 95, Number 1

Born at Oakland, California in January of 1919, Robert Edward Duncan was an American poet and a follower of Hilda Doolittle, a modernist poet who, with Ezra Pound, co-founded the Imagist group of poets. Duncan featured prominently in the histories of pre-Stonewall gay culture, bohemian communities of the Beat Generation, and cultural movements of the 1960s.

Born the tenth child of Edward Howard Duncan and Marguerite Pearl Wesley, Robert Duncan was adopted after the death of his mother by Edwin and Minnehaha Symmes. The prominent architect and his wife were a Theosophist family who embraced the spiritual teachings of Western esotericism as founded by Russian-American mystic and writer Helena Blavatsky. Robert Duncan grew up in a stable environment with new parents interested in both the occult and social community projects.

Encouraged by an English high school teacher, Duncan chose poetry as a vocation while still in his teens. After the death of Edwin Symmes in 1936, he began his studies at the University of California, Berkeley. While in his sophomore year, Duncan met graduate student Neo Fahs and entered into his first recorded homosexual relationship that lasted until 1940. While living in New York City with Fahs, he met many literary figures including playwright Arthur Miller and French-born essayist and writer Anaïs Nin.

During 1938, Robert Duncan briefly attended North Carolina’s Black Mountain College, an experimental educational project that became known for its artists and post-modernist poets. When he was drafted for military service in 1941, Duncan declared his homosexuality and was discharged. He became a prominent figure in the history of pre-Stonewall gay culture with his 1944 essay “The Homosexual in Society” published in editor and publisher Dwight Macdonald’s “Politics”, an outspoken magazine with articles by such notables as George Orwell, Lionel Trilling, and Mary McCarthy.

Duncan relocated to San Francisco in 1945 where he became friends with poets Helen Adam and Kenneth Rexroth as well as painter Lyn Brockway. He returned to U.C. Berkeley where he studied Medieval and Renaissance literature, eventually becoming a shamanistic figure in the artistic and poetry circles of San Francisco. Duncan’s first book, “Heavenly City Earthly City”, a collection of verse that reflected his admiration for the metaphysical work of British poet George Barker, was published by writer and physicist Bernard Porter’s newly founded Ben Porter Books in 1947.

In 1950, Robert Duncan met painter and collagist Jess Collins and began a relationship that would last thirty-seven years until Duncan’s death. They took marriage vows and settled in a historic Victorian home in San Francisco’s Mission District. Duncan began to publish his work regularly in the early 1950s and taught at Black Mountain College during 1956. His artistic and critical success occurred in the 1960s with the publishing of three volumes of poetic work: “Opening the Field” in 1960, the 1964 “Roots and Branches”, and “Bending the Bow” in 1968.

After the publication of his “Bending the Bow”, Duncan vowed not to publish another major collection for fifteen years. In 1984, his next major work “Ground Work I: Before the War” won the National Poetry Award. The concluding volume of Duncan’s poems, “Ground Work II: In the Dark”, taken as a whole was proposed by him in 1968 and later published in 1987.

Robert Duncan’s poetry is one of process not conclusion. It is considered Modernist for his inclination towards the impersonal, mythic and canonical styles; however, it is also seen as Romantic due to its organic, lyric and forward-wandering journey. Beginning in the 1960s, Duncan’s work was influenced by both “projective verse”, poetry that is shaped by the rhythms of the poet’s breath, and “composition by field”, the use of the page as a field of language beyond traditional margins and spacing. His work includes short lyrical poems and recurring sequences of prose poems, both of which draw inspiration from the poetic work of Walt Whitman, Ezra Pound, William Carlos Williams, and particularly that of modernist Charles John Olson and the Black Mountain School of poetry.

One of the most influential of the postwar American poets, Robert Duncan died in San Francisco in 1988 after a long battle with kidney disease. He was survived by his partner Jess Collins who died in January of 2004 at the age of eighty. Duncan’s papers are housed at the State University of New York-Buffalo and the Special Collections and Archives of Kent State University.

“There is a natural mystery in poetry. We do not understand all that we render up to understanding. . . I study what I write as I study out any mystery. I work at language as a spring of water works at the rock, to find a course, and so, blindly. In this I am not a maker of things, but, if maker, a maker of a way. For the way is itself.”—Robert Duncan, Notebook published in Donald Allen’s “The New American Poetry: 1945-1960”, First Edition, 1960, Grove Press, New York

Notes: The Archives of American Art has an online copy available for public viewing of Robert Duncan and Jess Collins’s scrapbook for Patricia Jordan at: https://www.aaa.si.edu/uv/index.html?manifest=https://www.aaa.si.edu/manifest/edanmdm:AAADCD_item_11139&c=0&m=0&s=0&cv=0&config=uv-config.json&locales=en-GB:English%20(GB)

Second Insert Image: Original Cover for Robert Duncan’s “Roots and Branches”, 1964, New Directions Publishing, New York

Third Insert Image: Jess Collins, Original Collage Illustration for Robert Duncan’s “The Opening of the Field”, 1960, Private Collection

Fourth Insert Image: Robert Duncan, “Bending the Bow”, 1968, 1st Edition, Publisher New Directions, New York

Bottom Insert Image: Jonathan Williams, “Robert Duncan”, Yale Collection of American Literature, Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library

John Wieners: “The Savagerey of the Sea”

Photographers Unknown, The Savagerey of the Sea

God love you
Dana my lover
lost in the horde
on this Friday night
500 men are moving up
& down from the bath
room to the bar.
Remove this desire
from the man I love.
Who has opened
the savagery
of the sea to me.

See to it that
his wants are filled
on California street
Bestow on him lan-
gesse that allows him
peace in his loins.

Leave him not
to the moths.
Make him out a lion
so that all who see him
hero worship his
thick chest as I did
moving my mouth
over his back bringing
our hearts to heights
I never hike over
anymore.
Let blond hair burn
on the back of his
neck, let no ache
screw his face
up in pain, his soul
is so hooked.
Not heroin.
Rather fix these
hundred men as his
lovers & lift him
with the enormous bale
of their desire.

6.20.58

John Wieners, A Poem for the Old Man, The Hotel Wentley Poems, 1958

Born in Boston in January of 1934, John Wieners was a poet and both an anti-war and gay rights activist. He was also a member of the San Francisco Renaissance, a movement which made that city the center of the American poetry avant-garde in the 1950s. Wieners studied from 1950 to 1954 at Boston College where he earned his Bachelor of Arts. After hearing a reading by postmodernist poet Charles Olson at Boston’s Charles Street Meeting House, Wieners enrolled at Black Mountain College where he studied under Olson and Robert Duncan, a modernist poet and shamanistic figure in San Francisco’s artistic and poetic circles.

In 1956 after returning to Boston, Wieners met visiting poets Frank O’Hara and Jack Spicer and became close friends with poet Stephen Jonas, a relationship which lasted until Jonas’s early death in 1970. He, along with Jonas, close friend Jim Dunn, Jack Spicer and poets Ed Marshall and Robin Blaser, formed a group which they labeled the School of Boston. All the members of the group, except for Dunn, were openly gay and congregated regularly in the bohemian Beacon Hill District. There they published limited-run chapbooks of poetry and the “Boston Newsletter”and “Measure”, both short-run publications which contained poems on queer vulnerability and survival.

In 1957, John Wieners relocated to the North Beach area of San Francisco with his boyfriend Dana Durkee. This relationship soon broke up. The result of which was a period of intense creativity for Wieners as he began to associate with the artistic and literary community of the city but it also led to a deterioration of his mental health. In San Francisco, he became closely associated with painter and set-designer Robert LaVigne and collage artist Wallace Berman, both of whom were involved in the Beat Movement.

In 1958 at the age of twenty-four, Wieners published his first collection of poems entitled “The Hotel Wentley Poems”, which contained both Beat and queer poems. Written during a six-day stay at the hotel in the queer Polk Gulch neighborhood, the poems balance the loss of his boyfriend Dana with the social atmosphere of the queer bars and friends. After this publication, he became a contributor to publisher Donald Allen’s influential “New American Poetry” anthology.

Worn down by an atmosphere of constant paranoia, homophobic landlords, drug busts and entrapment by undercover police, John Wieners’s mental health gradually declined. Arriving in New York, his erratic behavior from a drug cocktail prompted an acquaintance to call Wieners’s parents; damaging stays in several Massachusetts institutions followed. At Medfield State Hospital, Wieners lost his manuscripts and was threatened with electrical treatments. As an inpatient at Bournewood Hospital in Waltham, he was given ninety-one insulin treatments which caused memory loss.

Recovering at his parents’ home in Milton, Wieners continued his poetic writings in his notebooks and letters. His great poem “The Acts of Youth” was included in a January 1962 letter to his peer and former teacher Charles Olson; the poem alternates between visions of pain and suffering and dreams of resurrection. Wieners’s second collection of poems entitled “Ace of Pentacles” was published in 1964. In the following year, Wieners was engaged by Olson on a Guggenheim graduate fellowship at State University of New York, Buffalo.

In 1966 in Buffalo, John Wieners began the only significant hetero-relationship of his life with patron and heiress Panna Grady. That ended after Grady terminated a pregnancy and began a relationship with Charles Olson. In the following years, Wieners suffered a series of losses: the deaths of Olson, his friend Jonas, and both his parents. While inside another institution, the Central Islip State Hospital on Long Island, he heard about the 1969 Stonewall uprising from Charley Shively, a representative from the new Gay Liberation movement in Boston. This became one of the most important friendships in Wieners’s latter life.

Wieners began publishing poems, plays, and essays in Boston’s “Fag Rag”, a militant magazine published by Shively and others of the anarchist Fag Rag collective. The magazine was a medium for homosexual poetry, history, reviews and art that was sex-positive and which associated homosexuality not with tragedy but with joy. The collective later formed the Good Gay Poets Press in 1972, whose second publication was Wieners’s long poem “Playboy” which recounted Fag Rag’s presence at the 1072 Democratic convention in Miami. The Good Gay Poets Press also published Wieners’s full-length book “Behind the State Capital; or Cincinnati Pike” in 1975. A prominent theme in the book was Wieners’s defiance of traditional gender roles.

After the publication of “Behind the State Capital”, John Wieners nearly ceased writing poems and letters. Incapacitated by years of abusive mental health care, he lived frugally in his Beacon Hill neighborhood and became reliant on emotional and financial support from his old friends. Wieners continued to give occasional readings and worked on producing articles for the “Fag Rag” magazine. Its final issue in 1987 had a photograph of Wieners and Shively kissing at Gay Pride on its front cover.

John Wieners died on the 1st of March in 2002 , at his side were his longtime supporters and friends Charley Shively and Jim Dunn. Many of Wieners’s later writings were lost; many were never published. His papers are housed in several university collections and some of his late poems are in the Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library at Yale University.

John Wieners’s 1971 journal, discovered in the Kent State University archive collection, was published by Bootstrap Press with the title “A Book of Prophecies” in 2007. City Lights Bookstore and Publishers released “Stars Seen in Person: Selected Journals of John Wieners” in 2015; it contains selections from four unpublished journals written from 1955 to 1969. A comprehensive selection of Wieners’s poetry, “Supplication”, was published in 2015 by Wave Books.

Note: For those interested in the life and work of John Wieners, a must read is the Boston Review article by poet and scholar David Grundy entitled “Queer Shoulders at the Wheel”. This article was published in the May 2021 Arts in Society section : https://www.bostonreview.net/articles/queer-shoulders-at-the-wheel/

Jim Dunn’s article for the 2015 “I Have You By the Ears: John Wieners Ephemera” exhibition at Harvard’s Poetry Room can be found at: https://woodberrypoetryroom.com/?p=1793

Top Insert Image: Jerome Mallmann, “John Wieners”, Date Unknown, Gelatin Silver Print

Third Insert Image: Elsa Dorfman, “John Wieners”, Date Unknown, Gelatin Silver Print

Fourth Insert Image: Photographer Unknown, “John Wieners”, Date Unknown, Gelatin Silver Print

Bottom Insert Image: Photographer Unknown, “John Wieners, New York”, 1985, Gelatin Silver Print

Harold Norse: “The Sea Broke Wild Beneath the Cliff”

Photographers Unknown, The Sea Broke Wild Beneath the Cliff

we sailed into the harbor
all the church bells rang
the main street on the crescent shore
hung iridescent silks from windows
stucco house-fronts gleamed
rose, pistachio, peach
and a procession sang
behind a surpliced priest
carrying a burnished Christ
when I set foot on shore
a youth emerged from the crowd
barefoot and olive-skinned
and we climbed up rocky slopes
till dusk fell and close to the moon
at the mouth of a cave we made love
as the sea broke wild beneath the cliff

Harold Norse, Island of Giglio, In the Hub of the Fiery Force: Collected Poems of Harold Norse (1934-2003)

Born in New York City in July of 1916, Harold Norse, born Harold Rosen, was an American poet and writer who broke new ground beginning in the 1950s by his exploration of gay identity and sexuality through plain language and direct imagery.

The only son of an unmarried Lithuanian Jewish immigrant, Harold Norse earned his Bachelor of Arts degree in English Literature in 1938 from Brooklyn College where he edited its literary magazine and began writing poetry. While at the college, Norse entered into a relationship with fellow student Chester Kallman, who became a poet and opera librettist. He and Kallman became part of poet W. H. Auden’s inner circle of acquaintances after Auden and Christopher Isherwood relocated to New York City in 1939. Chester Kallman later became Auden’s companion until Auden’s death.

By the early 1940s as a member of Auden’s circle, Norse cultivated a number of relationships, both professional and personal. He met Allen Ginsberg on a Manhattan subway and became friends with James Baldwin after meeting him in Greenwich Village. Norse spent a summer with Tennessee Williams while the playwright finished his “The Glass Menagerie”, and in 1950 became friends with Welsh poet Dylan Thomas. After earning his Master’s Degree in English Literature at New York University in 1951, Norse met modernist poet William Carlos William who encouraged him to embrace a more direct, conversational language in his poetry.

After accepting Williams’s mentorship, Harold Norse found a common cause with the Beat Generation poets in their rejection of academic poetry and traditional metric formats. as well as, his peripheral status in society as a gay man. Norse began publishing his work in The Paris Review, The Saturday Review, and Poetry Magazine. In 1953, he published his first collection of poem, “The Undersea Mountain”. Frustrated with New York’s poetry scene, Norse began a fifteen year period of travel in Europe and North Africa. While in Italy, he translated the sonnets of Giuseppe Gioachino Belli from the Romanesco, the dialect of Rome, with the assistance of street hustlers.

Between 1960 and 1963, Norse lived in Paris , along with William Burroughs, Alan Ginsberg and Gregory Corso, at the hotel known as “The Bear” in the city’s Latin Quarter. He briefly collaborated with painter and performance artist Brion Gysin on Gysin’s cut-up Dada work. After traveling to Greece where he met songwriter and author Leonard Cohen, Norse went to North Africa where he became friends with stage actor Paul Bowles. He returned to the United States and settled in the Mission District of San Francisco in 1972, which became his home for the rest of his life.There he became friends with writer Charles Bukowski and met Arnold Schwarzenegger, at that time a beginning bodybuilder.

It was in San Francisco that Harold Norse’s literary career became very productive. In 1974, Lawrence Ferlinghetti’s publishing house, City Lights, released Norse’s “Hotel Nirvana” Selected Poems 1953-1973” to critical acclaim. With the publication of “Carnivorous Saint: Gay Poems 1941-1975″, he was considered one of America’s leading gay poets. Norse followed these successes with two more collections: “The Love Poems 1940-1985” and his final volume, “In the Hub of the Fiery Force: Collected Poems 1934-2003”. In 1989, his autobiography, “Memoirs of a Bastard Angel: A Fifty Year Literary and Erotic Odyssey”, was published.

Norse was an outsider of society, Jewish, homosexual and illegitimate, who produced new and technically accomplished work from the fringes of the literary scene in the United States. With the gay liberation movement gathering momentum, his poetry was given a new sense of direction and meaning. Norse wrote new poems about the idea of masculinity, such as his “I Am Not a Man”, and works about unrequited gay love and loneliness. In his latter years, his work reflected on what it meant to be an aged gay man in San Francisco.

Toward the end of his life, Harold Norse was surrounded by a group of friends who looked after him. He still read his poetry at the age of ninety-one to enthralled audiences. Both a two-time National Endowment of the Arts grant recipient and a National Poetry Association Award winner, Harold Norse died on the 8th of June in 2009.

Note: For those interested, I highly recommend a visit to the Harold Norse Centennial website. Dedicated to preserving the work and legacy of Norse, it was established by his close. decades-long friend Todd Swindell. The site contains interviews, readings of Norse’s work, book reviews, videos, photographs, and other articles. The site is located at: https://haroldnorse.com